Brother Jed: A Long Interview with the Smock Family

I’ve spent a lot of time blogging about Brother Jed Smock and his memorable, radical approach to campus preaching, but I never had a real conversation with him or his family until today.

Last Friday, Brother Jed announced to the University of Arizona that he has a Facebook account, and he encouraged everyone to add him to their friends list. After blogging about him a half dozen times, I thought I’d benefit from adding him as a friend on Facebook, and I ended up getting more from it than I expected. Brother Jed accepted my request and came across this blog, which he found entertaining, and he apologized for being short with me last month. His daughters sent me emails, and they invited me to chat with them on campus this afternoon.

Jed, Cindy, and their daughters, Martha and her sister arrived on the UA campus at 11:30 this morning. This is Brother Jed’s second week visiting the UA, and he leaves for Flagstaff on Wednesday morning. His daughters will fly back to Missouri, where they’re home schooled. Cindy and the girls don’t usually travel with their father, but they said they enjoy spending the extra time with him since he’s always away at college campuses.

“A lot of the things I say are tongue and cheek,” he began, and he seemed calmer when speaking in a regular voice as opposed to his booming shout, which draws the attention of students.

“When that young man kissed his hand and tried to touch me, I was feigning shock,” he said, noting that I picked up on his exaggerated horrors in my later blog entries.

“A lot of times, these students say things to shock me, but it’s never anything I haven’t heard thousands of times,” he said, laughing.

“To hold everyone’s attention, you have to put on a show,” he continued.

“But it works to our advantage,” added Cindy. “If we get ignored, it’s frustrating, but it’s usually due to bad weather.”

Brother Jed travels from campus to campus year-round. In the winter months, he visits Florida State University, Louisiana State University, University of Houston, University of Texas-Austin, Texam A&M, Arizona State, University of Arizona, UC-Davis, and several other western state colleges.

Jed Smock has been preaching for 35 years, and despite the physical and emotional drains of his job, he’s in good health. Every morning, he does 35 push-ups, 50 jumping jacks, and 15 sit-ups.

“I’d like to keep this job for another 30 years, or as long as I’m able.”

Jed’s ways seem to provoke an overriding negative reaction among students, but he feels his campus visits have been quite successful.

“We have changed people. I get a couple of emails a month about converted students. I’ve received so many emails that say something along the lines of, ‘you came to my campus in the 1980’s, and you made me so mad, I started reading the bible, and then I started going to church.’ We definitely see results.”

Perhaps Jed Smock’s biggest success story is his wife, Cindy, who he met in the late 1970’s when he preached at the University of Florida.

“Cindy made fun of me. I pointed her out in the audience and said, ‘repent your sins, wicked woman!’ Little did I know, that flattered her, and four years later, we were married.”

By the time Brother Jed came to Cindy’s college campus, he hadn’t kissed a girl in six years. Cindy saw this as a challenge, and she tried to get him to kiss her.

“You don’t go around kissing,” Jed told her, and dropped her off at her dorm immediately.

Thirty or so years later, they have five daughters, the oldest is 24 and the youngest 14. Evangeline is the oldest, and she serves as a chaplain’s assistant.

“With my old fashioned thinking, I wasn’t excited about her joining the military, but she wanted to serve and wouldn’t do it without my blessing, and my youngest daughter told me to give my consent, so I did.”


As Cindy Smock started to read bible passages to the crowd, Martha and her sister asked me to come sit by them. The three of us sat on their unfolded blanket, trying not to let the unusually fierce wind dictate the Brother Jed experience.

In Friday’s blog, I wondered about the Jed girls’ social lives, and they’re definitely not lacking in friends or social activity. Both 17-year-old Martha and her 14-year-old sister are home schooled, but they get together with a group of other home schooled students a few times a month, and they participate in a myriad of social activities.

“We organize a monopoly tournament, go skating, shopping, and have a prom, which we call an elegant evening because we dance like the women in Pride and Prejudice,” the sister said.

Though the girls aren’t allowed to date until they graduate high school, they get their fix for hanging out with boys.

“I have more guy friends than girl friends,” Martha shared. “When I was little, I wanted to be a boy. I climbed trees, and I’d always want to be the dad when my sisters and I played House.”

“I’m the youngest, but Martha was the oddball who got teased,” the sister said, giggling.

Last week, I was extremely curious as to how the Smock girls handle all the family ridicule and abuse among college students. After today, I can see that they’re completely desensitized to the negativity.

“We’re used to it, but when I was 4 years old, some guy wouldn’t stop yelling at my dad, so I kicked him. I was just a little kid, so it’s not like I was hurting him, though,” Martha said.

“Most people are nice to us. They were mean at Arizona State, but some guy spit on me here at UofA, and then ran away,” the sister said.

The girls get a feel for every campus they go to. When they were younger, Martha and her sister brought their doll houses to each school and ran around the campus. At Indiana, the girls would bring their swimsuits and jump into the water fountain. Here at UA, they walk through the campus, which her sister remarked as “beautiful,” dine at Panda Express, re-fill their sodas at Chick-Fil-A, and sometimes roam the UA Bookstore. Last week, the sister donned her new gray Arizona sweater. She tries to buy a hoodie at every college campus.

All five Smock daughters stay pretty busy. Charlotte studied Nursing at Pensacola Christian College in Florida, but hated the “strict Christian rules” about clothing among other things, so she left. Justina is married with a baby girl, and Evangeline is married as well. The remaining high school girls have ideas about what they’d like to do once they graduate.

“I want to do something with fashion,” the sister said.

Martha wasn’t sure what kind of career appealed to her, but the sister later mentioned that Martha would like to help her dad with campus preaching after high school graduation.

“Have you ever thought about applying to college?” I asked.

“I’ll go if I want to.”

When asked about Evolution, the sister said, “I don’t worry about it. I have faith that God created the universe.”

That’s when I brought up my own views. I believe in Evolution, but I also believe in God, and I asked the sister if she thought it was wrong for someone to pick and choose what to believe in the bible.

“As long as you have religion, it doesn’t really matter.”

Jed and Cindy waited until their wedding day to have their first kiss as a couple, and their daughters expressed a desire to follow this route.

“My dad wouldn’t mind if I kissed before marriage, but it’s my choice not to do it,” said Martha.

“If I got married, but had done stuff with other guys before, I wouldn’t be giving my whole heart to my husband,” said the sister.

“Have you ever thought it would be hard to meet a guy who is willing to wait until marriage to kiss you?” I asked.

After a pause, the sister answered, “If he really loved me, he wouldn’t mind.”

But holding hands and hugging is permitted. The girls like to dance, and they see no problem with
that, and they thought it was strange that some of their friends aren’t even allowed to hug boys or be friends with them on

Brother Jed began speaking out against masturbation, and a young male student questioned why Jed doesn’t do it.

“I don’t need to, I get the real thing! Cindy is all over me!”

“Is it humiliating to hear about your parents’ sex lives?” I asked the girls.

“Yes!” they answered in unison.

“It’s weird when he talks about his fraternity days and bad past,” Martha said.

“I only get really embarrassed when he brings out the electrical cords for his homosexuality demonstration,” the sister said. “I hate when my friends find it online.”

With many exceptions, the girls remind me of myself in high school. They watch American Idol as I did, and they’re up to date on the lives of Ashley Tisdale, Hilary Duff, Katy Perry, and the Jonas Brothers. They grew up watching The Sound of Music, Fiddler on the Roof, and other musicals. Like every teenage girl, Martha is excited to get her license, and she credits Brother Jed as her preferred parental driving instructor.

The girls play instruments, and they said they’d be friends with sinners so long as the sinners don’t put any pressure on them.

“Our best friend, Nikki isn’t Christian,” Martha added.

I decided to ask more religious questions, and I wanted to know more about her family’s take on homosexuality. It’s one thing to see Brother Jed scold gays in front of a crowd, but a different experience to hear the family seriously discuss the reality of the situation.

The five daughters are heterosexual, but life wouldn’t be good for them if they weren’t.

“If one of us were a lesbian, we’d probably get kicked out of the house,” Martha said.

I furthered on the gay lifestyle, which the girls think is a choice.

“Why would Jesus plan for someone to be gay and basically condemn him to Hell from birth? He’s a loving God, he won’t lead us into sin.”

Believe it or not, though, the girls feel they have a “happy medium” between party girls and Amish girls.

“We’re stereotyped as being one or the other, but we’re in the middle.”

The sister also said it frustrates her that Christian girls get penalized for misbehaving when other girls do the same things and get away with it.

“If I wore a shirt that revealed my boobs, I’d be called out for being Christian and doing it even though tons of other girls do the same thing on a daily basis.”

“So yeah, we do have social lives,” Martha said, grinning as she alluded to my blog entry in question of that.

The girls delved into some of the more serious violent acts against their parents on campus visits. Brother Jed broke his leg and arm, and he has been pushed off walls. Cindy was also pushed into a fountain. When a crowd went wild, Brother Jed was arrested for his own safety. On a less destructive level, a UA student threw ice cream at Jed, and another student stuck a piece of gum on Jed’s chair. The girls used ice to remove the gum. Today alone, someone threw a water balloon at Jed, Cindy, and the sister, but it missed and hit an on-looker.

Even though the Smock daughters live what most would consider a restricted life, they’re level-headed and genuinely happy, and from my observations, they are much better behaved and stable than most girls their age. It was refreshing to talk to teenage girls about something besides drinking and parties as the main conversational focuses, and they seem to have a lot of self-respect and pride in what they do. Martha isn’t crying over boys as I was at 17, and the sister isn’t concerned with rushing into adolescent mischief as most high school freshman girls are. I can see they’re truly happy with their decisions, even if the choices don’t always make sense to me or anyone else. Though I’m considerably more sinful than the Smock girls, I appreciated talking to them because they have a more meaningful thought process than a lot of college students I encounter, who seek shallow friendships and drink to fill voids that the Smock daughters don’t have.

My good friend, Rob sat next to me and the Smock girls around 2:15, when Jed began his lecture on pre-marital kissing.

“I waited four years of dating to kiss my wife!”

“Wow, I thought two months was bad,” Rob noted.

“Tell me about it, it’s been since July for me,” I said. “I’m picky.”

That was when the girls stood up from the blanket, setting a chair down on it so it wouldn’t blow away.

“We’re going to go study at the library now,” they said, and then they walked off. I hoped I hadn’t made them uncomfortable. After all, they did say that they have several friends who chose to abstain from kissing until marriage.

“They seem really cool,” Rob said, watching the girls descend the grassy hill.

You can say all you want about the Smock family’s evangelism, but the girls were raised well. Any student with an opinion on Brother Jed should approach him individually. It’ll be different than watching him from the top of Heritage Hill. The family views remain the same, but they do not live as radical a lifestyle as you’d expect. The girls love their lives, and Cindy greatly misses Jed while he’s away. She wants to travel full-time with him when the sister graduates high school. Whether or not you agree with their beliefs, they’re happier than the average American family.


18 thoughts on “Brother Jed: A Long Interview with the Smock Family

  1. Wow! I think it’s amazing that you got to sit down and have a good, solid discussion with Brother Jed and Co. I think I’ll take back what I said about him being nuts in light of this interview. Way to go, Laura!

  2. Thank you, Jimi!! You should talk to him, too. It’s a whole different experience to sit down and chat with them. Most people have no idea. The family still believes all the same stuff they preach, but now we know they don’t run around the house yelling about religion. They try to lead relatively normal lives.

  3. Hey, I’m a cultural anthropologist at the University of Florida, and I’ve been making a study of the evangelical street preachers that come through our campus for about 18 months now.

    I’ve visited your site more-than-a-few times and thought you might be interested in some of the films I’ve made about them…
    and (you wanna check out the earlier chapters)
    …I’m serious, after reading some of your work, I’d like to hear your thoughts on mine.

    Also, do you know if Brother Jed comes through UF at all? I’ve heard a lot of talk about him, but I’ve never seen him in person.

  4. Why anyone would set out to legitimize a hateful character (I don’t care what this interview says, frankly..I care how people act in public, it shows their true self) like this is beyond me.

    1. Hey, Jon

      Believe it or not, I understand your hate.

      But try to bear in mind that, regardless of whether-or-not he’s correct in his belief, Smock HONESTLY SEEMS TO BELIEVE that he’s trying to save our souls from Hell. In his culture, it would actually be an insult if he didn’t preach at us the way he does; it would mean he doesn’t care.

      And yes, I understand that his name-calling and sometimes psychologically “abusive” approach can inspire hate amongst people like you and I… and I understand that it seems terribly ineffective… but remember, the way our own culture is wired, the only four ways to assuredly get attention is with (1) free money giveaways, (2) sex appeal, (3) violence, or (4) offensive language.

      Since he probably doesn’t have much money to giveaway, his own culture prohibits him from using sex appeal, and violence is illegal… his only option is offensive language.

      Which, typically, makes us hate him.
      Even though he thinks he’s caring for us.

      Just sayin’.

  5. I don’t understand the thinking behind Jed Smock’s ministry. I know he’s trying to scare us all straight, and it has been effective for some people. For someone who can practically recite the Bible, it doesn’t seem like he really understood God’s message out of it. Let us not forget that we are born into sinful nature and despite living life with a “clean” record we are yet sinners. But more importantly, we should NEVER forget or neglect to mention the fact that Christ died for our sins because he loves us. Without love, we are like a clanging cymbal, and when Jed speaks, all I hear is noise.

    It’s nice to hear that he has a kind side when he’s not preaching, but shouldn’t kindness be our only side? Shouldn’t he demonstrate Christ’s love for the sinners? Even by talking down to them he is sinning, I wonder if he realizes that. Forget the so-called “good intentions” for his facade of hatred or this lie that the only way to reach people is to appeal to their sinful nature. What people really want–what the gospel is–is love. That’s it.

    Now, I like the fact that it opens a dialogue for students, but it breaks my heart to hear such misinterpretations of what God is about. The upside to this is that if there are Christians who are willing to stand for Christ and his love, Jed provides a good contrast for students to cling to the true gospel of Christ. I encourage any Christians reading this to get involved, speak with some ministries, form a plan, and always remember it’s about LOVE.

    1. First of all I have met the smock and they are super nice people 🙂 I love them all like family. second of all the Bible is not ALL about love…take the chaper of acts, not one mention of it, im 18 and know that. even Jesus got angry and threw stuff now and then. paul (in acts) once yelled and called names at people just as jed does, did he do it wrong? The Bible says to go and warn people of their sins. its disgusting that people see their friends getting drunk and having pre-marital sex and not saying anything against it. in my oppinion that makes people hypocrites. again I say its not all love, parents LOVE you but dont go around saying it when you steal somthing from a store, they dont talk politely when you curse at someone, they get mad and have to talk harsh to get the point across. kinda like jed talks harsh so these people will understand god LOVES you but does NOT love how they are living.

  6. In fall of 2008, Jed Smock’s daughter Justina had a baby out of wedlock. Jed and Cindy were embarrassed but later had to admit this. So much for his “5 pure virgin daughters”.

    Jed permitted Cindy to attend the birth of their new granddaughter (“bastard”, as Jed always puts it).

    Jed and Cindy pressured Justina and boyfriend to marry and repent their sin of fornication, though I understand Jed refused to attend the wedding.

    1. Where did you hear about this? To be honest, it sounds quite plausible. He has since forgiven his daughter, I think, being that he boasts about his grandchild and has invited her to Christmas brunches and other family gatherings.

      1. It was on his forum about a year ago:

        Much of that board has been taken down, but if you email Smock he will verify it.

        The (now) son-in-law is named Tyler Hughey. He was barely able to complete his GED, and Justina has been making ends meet by cleaning houses. If I can find an archive of Jed’s posting on this subject, I will provide it.

  7. Can you tell me how they earn a living? All that travelling has to be expensive. And one of the daughters buys a hoodie at every university they preach at… Do they have regular jobs too? Or do they have a church where people fun their travels?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s